Who got the better of the trade? 10pts!?

I would say that player one definitely got the better deal. While Posey is still young, he has done a nice job of producing runs. Ichiro is of course one of the best players in the game. As for player two, Peavy is good, but he has been a lot more unpredictable this year in the AL. Jay Bruce is a good player, but he still hasn't been able to maximize his potential. Posey and Ichiro are way more consistent, and I think that makes this deal a win for player 1.